ADVISORY LANDSCAPE

Strategy Advisor Index

A comparison of 15 strategy consulting firm methodologies across four dimensions: positioning, commercialization focus, implementation depth, and enterprise integration. These are provided for prospects to evaluate the viability of their strategy and where to seek advisory services from The Brushton Group.

15

Firms in view

3

MBB firms

8

High commercialization

12

High enterprise integration

Commercialization
Implementation
Enterprise integration
FirmCategoryComm.Impl.Enterprise
AccentureGlobal integratedHighVery highVery high
AlixPartnersSpecialistHighVery highHigh
Bain & CompanyMBBMediumHighMedium
Boston Consulting GroupMBBHighHighHigh
Deloitte ConsultingBig FourHighVery highVery high
EY-ParthenonBig FourHighHighHigh
KearneyTier 2MediumHighHigh
KPMGBig FourMediumVery highVery high
LEK ConsultingTier 2MediumMediumMedium
McKinsey & CompanyMBBHighHighHigh
Oliver WymanTier 2MediumHighHigh
PwC Strategy&Big FourMediumHighHigh
Roland BergerTier 2MediumHighHigh
Simon-KucherSpecialistVery highMediumMedium
ZSSpecialistVery highHighHigh

Global integrated

Accenture

The largest global integrated consultancy, combining strategy, technology, and operations at scale. Strongest where growth strategy must be paired with deep technology execution, digital reinvention, and customer experience design.

Growth strategy linked to reinvention, technology, and experience.

HighVery highVery high

Angle

Strongest tech and execution integration outside classic strategy firms.

Commercialization

High

Implementation

Very high

Enterprise

Very high

About this index

How to read the categories, columns, and value levels in the comparison above.

Categories

  • MBB. Industry shorthand for McKinsey, Bain, and BCG. The three top-tier strategy consulting firms by reputation, fee rates, and senior-executive access.
  • Big Four. Deloitte, PwC, EY, and KPMG. The four largest professional services firms globally, originally audit practices that now span audit, tax, consulting, and advisory.
  • Tier 2. Mid-sized global strategy firms with strong brands and capabilities but lower fee rates and brand premium than MBB. Examples here: Kearney, Oliver Wyman, LEK, Roland Berger.
  • Global integrated. Large firms combining strategy, technology, and operations at scale, typically with tens of thousands of employees and a technology-implementation core. Accenture is the canonical example.
  • Specialist. Firms focused on a specific function (pricing, commercial execution) or industry rather than broad corporate strategy. Examples here: AlixPartners, ZS, Simon-Kucher.

Measurement columns

  • Commercialization (Comm.). How much the firm emphasizes go-to-market, sales motion, pricing, and revenue generation in its growth-strategy work. Higher means the firm treats commercial execution as a primary deliverable, not an afterthought.
  • Implementation (Impl.). How deeply the firm engages in execution after the strategy is set: operating model design, organizational change, technology deployment, program management. Higher means longer engagements and more execution staff on the ground.
  • Enterprise integration. How broadly the firm spans functions across the enterprise: strategy plus technology plus operations plus people plus risk. Higher means a single firm can deliver multi-function transformation without external partners.

Value levels

  • Very high. The firm leads the market on this attribute.
  • High. The firm is strong on this attribute and competes for engagements where it matters.
  • Medium. The firm has capability here but does not lead with it.

How does your strategy score?

A nine-question self-assessment based on the same dimensions Brushton uses to benchmark client engagements. Takes about four minutes.

Looking for a different kind of engagement? Learn more about The Brushton Group.